Whatnot Review 2024 – Actually Legit Live Auctions?

Fancy a Sacagawea Dollar? How about a Star Note? Well, let me introduce you to Whatnot – a pretty great platform that can help you get your hands on some of the coolest and most valuable collectibles around in 2024.

In this Whatnot review I’m going to delve into the intricacies of the platform, exploring its features, audience, and the overall experience it offers. I’ve also shared my personal experience using Whatnot, both as a buyer and a seller. And, as a bonus to my readers, I’m going to share how you can get started with $15 free credit – no strings attached.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a casual browser, read on to find out why Whatnot could be your next favorite online destination.

What is Whatnot?

Imagine if eBay, the go-to platform for all things collectible, and Twitch, the live-streaming service, had a baby. The result would be Whatnot—a live video auction platform where you can find an astonishing array of collectibles ranging from trading cards and sports memorabilia to coins, precious metals, and much more. 

Unlike traditional online auction sites that rely solely on text and images, Whatnot brings the auction experience to life by incorporating live video streams. Sellers host these streams, showcasing items from collectible trading cards and sports memorabilia to more niche categories like coins, precious metals, comics, antiques, and even sneakers.

This unique model  allows buyers and sellers to interact in real-time, ask questions, discuss items, and even negotiate prices on the spot. The experience is not just about buying or selling; it’s a social event where community members can engage, learn, and have fun.

Whatnot at a Glance

✅Community engagement
✅Entertainment value
✅Transparency & trust
✅Deals & giveaways
✅Seller & buyer protection

❌Time commitment
❌Potentially limited selection

Who is Whatnot for?

Whatnot caters to a broad audience, making it an ideal platform for various types of users. At its core, it’s designed for collectors—those who are passionate about acquiring specific items to complete or enhance their collections. Whether you’re a seasoned collector of rare coins, a sports memorabilia enthusiast, or someone who loves trading cards, Whatnot has something to offer you.

But the platform goes beyond just catering to collectors. Its community-driven and entertainment-focused approach also makes it appealing to casual browsers and enthusiasts. Even if you’re not looking to buy, the live video streams offer a form of entertainment where you can learn about different items, engage in discussions, and be part of a community with similar interests.

Moreover, the platform is excellent for those who enjoy the thrill of live auctions but want the convenience of participating from the comfort of their home. The real-time interaction allows for a dynamic and exciting auction experience that traditional online platforms often lack.

In summary, Whatnot is for:

  • Collectors looking for specific items to add to their collections.
  • Enthusiasts interested in learning more about various collectibles.
  • Casual browsers seeking entertainment and community engagement.
  • Individuals who enjoy live auctions but prefer the convenience of online participation.
  • So, whether you’re in it for the collectibles, the community, or the sheer entertainment value, Whatnot offers a unique experience that is worth exploring.

Who Sells on Whatnot?

The sellers on Whatnot are a diverse group, adding another layer of richness to the platform. Many are social media influencers, experts, or thought leaders in their respective fields of collectibles. This means that not only are you buying from someone who knows their stuff, but you’re also getting the added value of their expertise. Whether it’s a detailed backstory of a rare comic book or the historical significance of a particular coin, the sellers often provide insights that you won’t find in a typical online listing.

The types of items offered by sellers can range from popular collectibles like trading cards and sports memorabilia to more niche items like antiques, records, and precious metals. This diversity ensures that there’s something for everyone, regardless of how specialized your interests may be.

In summary, sellers on Whatnot are:

  • Often experts or influencers in their respective fields.
  • Vetted and verified by the platform for credibility.
  • Offering a wide range of items, from popular to niche collectibles.
  • The combination of expertise, trust, and diversity among sellers makes Whatnot a compelling platform for both buyers and collectors alike.

Is Whatnot Legit?

In short, YES.

What sets Whatnot apart is its vetting process for sellers. Unlike other platforms where virtually anyone can list an item, Whatnot ensures that all sellers are vetted and verified. This creates a level of trust and reliability that can sometimes be lacking on other online marketplaces. You can bid with confidence, knowing that the person on the other end has been screened for credibility and expertise.

Whatnot Review: My Experience

I’ve been an active seller and buyer on Whatnot for a while now. Just check out what I got up to during my most recent auction:

I’m not just a seller either. I’m a proud buyer. I even won some pretty cool stuff in a recent Whatnot drop, which you can check out in my video at the top of this page.

As you can see, I’m a fan. But don’t worry, I’ve gone into a lot more detail below on what you can expect, including some of the challenges you might face using Whatnot – and how to overcome them to ensure you get the most out of this amazing platform.

Pros of Whatnot

Community Engagement

One of the standout features of Whatnot is the strong sense of community it fosters. Unlike other platforms like eBay, where transactions are often impersonal, Whatnot offers a social experience. Regular attendees come to auctions not just to bid but to engage in meaningful conversations, making the platform more than just a marketplace.

Entertainment Value

Whatnot isn’t just about buying and selling; it’s an event. The live video streams add a layer of excitement and entertainment that is often missing from traditional online auctions. Whether you’re there to bid or just to watch, there’s a fun and dynamic atmosphere that keeps you engaged.

Transparency & Trust

The live interactions with sellers add a layer of transparency and trust that is invaluable in the world of online auctions. Sellers are vetted and verified, and the real-time nature of the auctions means they can’t hide behind a keyboard. This creates a safer and more reliable environment for buyers.

Deals and Giveaways

The platform offers numerous opportunities to snag great deals, especially on less popular or niche items. The giveaways, often conducted by sellers during the auctions, add an extra layer of excitement and offer attendees the chance to win valuable items.

Seller and Buyer Protection

Whatnot takes the security of its users seriously. With a rigorous vetting process for sellers and built-in protections for buyers, the platform ensures that transactions are conducted with the utmost integrity.

Challenges of Whatnot

Time Commitment

One of the challenges of using Whatnot is the need to be present during the live auctions. This real-time commitment may not be convenient for everyone, especially those who are used to the “set and forget” nature of traditional online auctions.

Limited Selection

While the platform offers a wide range of items, the selection is ultimately dependent on what sellers have available at that moment. This means you may not always find the specific item you’re looking for, especially if it’s a rare or highly specialized collectible.

In summary, while Whatnot offers a plethora of advantages that make it a compelling choice for collectors and enthusiasts, it does come with its own set of challenges that potential users should be aware of.

The Risk-Free Way to Get Started on Whatnot in 2024 – $15 FREE Credit!

While Whatnot does have its challenges, the platform offers a way to mitigate some of these concerns, particularly for newcomers who may be hesitant to dive in. When you sign up using my link, you’ll receive $15 of free credit. This allows you to participate in auctions and potentially win some valuable items without any initial financial commitment, making your first experience on the platform essentially risk-free.

This free credit is an excellent opportunity to familiarize yourself with the platform’s features, engage with the community, and even add a new item or two to your collection without any out-of-pocket expense. It’s a win-win situation that lets you explore Whatnot’s unique offerings while alleviating concerns about time commitment and selection limitations.

So, if the idea of a live, interactive auction platform appeals to you, but you’re wary of the challenges, this deal offers the perfect solution. It’s a low-risk way to experience the community engagement, entertainment value, and exciting deals that Whatnot has to offer. Get it now.

Whatnot Alternatives

Even though I’m definitely a Whatnot evangelist, I know that, sometimes it’s not the right solution depending on your needs. If that’s the case, there are a couple of good alternatives:


If you’re know what you’re looking for and are happy to pay whatever it takes, Apmex is your best friend. It’s got a huge selection of coins and currency, and you can rest assured that every item is verified to the highest standard of quality and authenticity.

The Silverpicker’s District Marketplace

If you’re looking for more interesting things, but can’t make one of my auctions (or simply don’t want the bidding process), I’ve got a store over at District. Sellers and friends of the Silverpicker showcase their items in my marketplace, and you can be sure there’ll always be something to pique your interest.

For my full summary on buying coins, currency, and precious metals, check out my Buying Guide.

Whatnot Review Summary

Whatnot provides a refreshing and engaging twist to the online auction landscape. With its focus on community, entertainment, and transparency, it’s more than just a marketplace—it’s a social experience that any collector or enthusiast should consider exploring. And when you can get started for free, there’s no reason not to give it a try in 2024 and beyond.

Scroll to Top